Saint Basil's Cathedral

Saint Basil's Cathedral
Cathedral of Intercession of Most Holy Theotokos on the Moat, Temple of Basil the Blessed

View of the cathedral
Location Red Square, Moscow
Country Russia
Denomination Russian Orthodox
Website State Historical Museum
History
Founded 1555
Founder(s) Ivan IV
Architecture
Architect(s) Barma and Postnik

The Cathedral of Intercession of Theotokos on the Moat (Russian: Собор Покрова пресвятой Богородицы, что на Рву), popularly known as Saint Basil's Cathedral (Russian: Собор Василия Блаженного), is a Russian Orthodox cathedral erected on the Red Square in Moscow in 1555–1561. Built on the order of Ivan IV of Russia to commemorate the capture of Kazan and Astrakhan, it marks the geometric center of the city and the hub of its growth since the 14th century.[1][2] It was the tallest building of Moscow until the completion of the Ivan the Great Bell Tower in 1600.[3]

The original building, known as "Trinity Church" and later "Trinity Cathedral", contained eight side churches arranged around the ninth, central church of Intercession; the tenth church was erected in 1588 over the grave of venerated local Fool Vasily (Basil). In the 16th and the 17th centuries the cathedral, perceived as the earthly symbol of the Heavenly City,[4] was popularly known as the "Jerusalem" and served as an allegory of the Jerusalem Temple in the annual Palm Sunday parade attended by the Patriarch of Moscow and the tsar.[5]

The building's design, shaped as a flame of a bonfire rising into the sky,[6] has no analogues in Russian architecture: "It is like no other Russian building. Nothing similar can be found in the entire millennium of Byzantine tradition from the fifth to fifteenth century... a strangeness that astonishes by its unexpectedness, complexity and dazzling interleaving of the manifold details of its design."[7] The cathedral foreshadowed the climax of Russian national architecture in the 17th century[8] but has never been reproduced directly.

The cathedral has operated as a division of the State Historical Museum since 1928.[9] It was completely secularized in 1929[9] and, as of 2009, remains a federal property of the Russian Federation. The cathedral has been part of the Moscow Kremlin and Red Square UNESCO World Heritage Site since 1990.[10]

Contents

Design and construction

Red Square, early 17th century. Fragment from Bleau Atlas. The structure with three roof tents in foreground left is the original detached belfry of the Trinity Cathedral, drawn not to scale. Trinity Cathedral stands behind it, slightly closer to the road starting at St. Frol's (later Saviour's ) Gate of the Kremlin. The horseshoe-shaped object near the road in the foreground is Lobnoye Mesto.

Ivan's order

The site of the cathedral has been, historically, a busy marketplace between the St. Frol's (later Saviour's) Gate of the Moscow Kremlin and the outlying posad. The center of the marketplace was marked by the Trinity Church, built of the same white stone as the Kremlin of Dmitry Donskoy (1366–1368) and its cathedrals. Tsar Ivan IV marked every victory of the Russo-Kazan War by erecting a wooden memorial church next to the walls of Trinity Church; by the end of his Astrakhan campaign it was literally shrouded within a cluster of seven wooden churches. According to the sketchy report in Nikon's Chronicle, in the autumn of 1554 Ivan ordered construction of a wooden Church of Intercession on the same site, "on the moat".[11] One year later Ivan ordered construction of a new stone cathedral on the site of Trinity Church that would commemorate his campaigns. Dedication of a church to a military victory was "a major innovation"[7] for Muscovy. The placement of the church outside of the Kremlin walls was a political statement in favour of posad commoners, and against hereditary boyars.[12]

Chronists clearly identified the new building as Trinity Church, after its easternmost sanctuary;[11] the status of "sobor" (cathedral) has not been bestowed on it yet:

“ On the Trinity on the Moat in Moscow.
In the same year, through the will of tsar and lord and grand prince Ivan began making the pledged church, as he promised for the capture of Kazan: Trinity and Intercession and seven sanctuaries, also called "on the moat". And the builder was Barma with company.		 ”

Identity of the architect or architects is unknown.[14] Tradition held that the cathedral was built by two architects, Barma and Postnik:[14][15] the official Russian cultural heritage register lists "Barma and Postnik Yakovlev".[16] Researchers proposed that both names refer to the same person, Postnik Yakovlev[15] or, alternatively, Ivan Yakovlevich Barma (Varfolomey).[14] Legend held that Ivan blinded the architect so that he could not recreate the masterpiece elsewhere,[17][18] although the real Postnik Yakovlev remained active at least throughout the 1560s.[19] There is evidence that construction involved stonemasons from Pskov[20] and German lands.[21]

Roots and sources

A church in Kolomenskoye, a probable influence on the cathedral[22]

The cathedral has no analogues, even remote, in preceding, contemporary or later architecture of Muscovy and Byzantine cultural tradition in general;[7] the sources that inspired Barma and Postnik are disputed. Eugène Viollet-le-Duc rejected European roots for the cathedral; according to him, its corbel arches were Byzantine, and ultimately Asian.[23] A modern "Asian" hypothesis considers the cathedral a recreation of Qolsharif Mosque, which was destroyed by Russian troops after the siege of Kazan.[24]

Nineteenth century Russian writers, starting with Ivan Zabelin,[4] emphasized the influence of the vernacular wooden churches of the Russian North; their motifs made their ways into masonry, particularly the votive churches that did not need to house substantial congregations.[25] David Watkin also wrote of a blend of Russian and Byzantine roots, calling the cathedral "the climax" of Russian vernacular wooden architecture.[26]

The cathedral combines the staggered layered design of the earliest (1505–1508) part of the Ivan the Great Bell Tower,[27] the central tent of the Church of Ascension in Kolomenskoye (1530s), and the cylindric shape of the Church of Beheading of John the Baptist in Dyakovo (1547),[22] but the origin of these unique buildings is equally debated. The Church in Kolomenskoye, according to Sergey Podyapolsky, was built by Italian Petrok Maly[21] although mainstream history has not yet accepted his opinion. Andrey Batalov revised the year of completion of Dyakovo church from 1547 to 1560s–1570s, and noted that Trinity Cathedral could have had no tangible predecessors at all.[28]

Dmitry Shvidkovsky suggested that the "improbable" shapes of the Intercession Cathedral and the Church of Ascension in Kolomenskoye manifested an emerging national renaissance, blending earlier Muscovite elements with the influence of Italian Renaissance.[29] A large group of Italian architects and craftsmen continuously worked in Moscow in 1474–1539, as well as Greek refugees that arrived in the city after the fall of Constantinople.[30] These two groups, according to Shvidkovsky, helped Moscow rulers in forging the doctrine of Third Rome which, in turn, promoted assimilation of contemporary Greek and Italian culture.[30] Shvidkovsky noted the resemblance of the cathedral's floorplan to Italian concepts by Antonio da Sangallo the Younger and Donato Bramante, but most likely Filarete's Trattato di architettura. Other Russian researchers noted a resemblance to sketches by Leonardo da Vinci, although he could not have been known in Ivan's Moscow.[31] Nikolay Brunov recognized the influence of these prototypes but not their significance;[32] he suggested that in the middle of the 16th century Moscow already had local architects trained in Italian tradition, architectural drawing and perspective, and that this culture was lost during the Time of Troubles.[33]

Andrey Batalov wrote that, judging by the amount of novel elements introduced with Trinity Cathedral, it was most likely built by German craftsmen.[21] Batalov and Shvidkovsky noted that in Ivan's reign, Germans and Englishmen replaced Italians although German influence peaked later, in the reign of Mikhail Romanov.[21] German influence is indirectly supported by the rusticated pilasters of the central church, a feature more common in contemporary Northern Europe than in Italy.[34]

The 1983 academic edition of Monuments of architecture in Moscow takes middle ground: the cathedral is, most likely, a product of the complex interaction of distinct Russian traditions of wooden and stone architecture, with some elements borrowed from the works of Italians in Moscow.[35] Specifically, the style of brickwork in the vaults is Italian.[35]

Layout

Plan of the first floor (western facade at the bottom) with central hall offset relative to corner towers

Instead of literally following the original ad hoc layout (seven churches around the central core), Ivan's architects opted for a symmetrical floor plan with "eight" side churches around the core,[15] producing "a thoroughly coherent, logical plan"[36][37] despite the erroneous latter "notion of a structure devoid of restraint or reason"[36] influenced by the memory of Ivan's irrational atrocities.[36] The central core and the four larger churches placed on compass points are octagonal, the four diagonally placed smaller churches are cuboid although their shape is barely visible through later additions.[38] The larger churches firmly stand on their massive foundations, while the smaller ones were placed on a raised platform, as if hovering above ground.[39]

Although the side churches are arranged in perfect symmetry, the cathedral as a whole is not.[40][41] The larger central church was deliberately[40] offset to the west from the geometric center of the side churches, to accommodate its larger apse[40] on the eastern side. As a result of this subtle calculated[40] asymmetry viewing from north and south presents a complex multi-axial shape while the western facade, facing the Kremlin, appears properly symmetrical and monolithic.[40][41] The latter perception is reinforced by fortress-style machicolation and corbeled cornice of the western church of Entry into Jerusalem, mirroring real fortifications of the Kremlin.[42]

Inside the cathedral is a labyrinth of narrow vaulted corridors and vertical cylinders of the churches.[22] The largest, central church of the Intercession is 46 meters tall internally but has a floor area of only 64 square meters.[22] Nevertheless, it is wider and more "airy" than the church in Kolomenskoye with its exceptionally thick walls.[43] The corridors functioned as internal parvises; the western corridor, adorned with a unique flat caissoned ceiling, doubled as the narthex.[22]

The detached belfry of the original Trinity Cathedral stood south-west or south from the main structure. Late 16th and early 16th century plans depict a simple structure with three roof tents, most likely covered with sheet metal.[44] No buildings of this type survived to date, although it was then common and used in all pass-through towers of Skorodom.[45] August von Meyerberg's panorama (1661) presents a different building, with a cluster of small onion domes.[44]

Structure

The small dome on the left marks the sanctuary of Basil the Blessed (1588).

Foundations, traditionally to medieval Moscow, were built of white stone, while the churches themselves were built of red brick (28×14×8 centimeters), then a relatively new material[15] (the first attested brick building in Moscow, the new Kremlin Wall, was launched in 1485).[46] Surveys of the structure showed that the basement level is perfectly aligned, indicating use of professional drawing and measurement, but each subsequent level becomes less and less regular.[47] Restorators who replaced parts of the brickwork in 1954–1955 discovered that the massive brick walls conceal an internal wooden frame running the whole height of the church.[4][48] This frame, made of elaborately tied thin studs, was erected as a life-size spatial model of the future cathedral and was gradually enclosed in solid masonry.[4][48]

The builders, fascinated by flexibility of the new technology,[49] used brick as decorative medium inside and outside, leaving as much brickwork open as possible; when location required use of stone walls, they decorated it with brickwork pattern painted over stucco.[49] A major novelty introduced by the cathedral was the use of strictly "architectural" means of exterior decoration.[50] Sculpture and sacred symbols employed by earlier Russian architecture are completely missing, floral ornaments are a later addition;[50] instead, the cathedral boasts a diversity of three-dimensional architectural elements executed in brick.

Colour

The cathedral acquired its present-day vivid colors in several stages from 1680s[4] to 1848[35]. Russians' attitude to color in the 17th century changed in favor of bright colors; icon and mural art experienced an explosive growth in number of available paints, dyes and their combinations.[51] The original color scheme, missing these innovations, was far less challenging. It followed the depiction of Heavenly City in the Book of Revelation:[52]

“ And he that sat was to look upon like a jasper and a sardine stone: and there was a rainbow round about the throne, in sight like unto an emerald.
And round about the throne were four and twenty seats: and upon the seats I saw four and twenty elders sitting, clothed in white raiment; and they had on their heads crowns of gold.		 ”

Twenty-five seats of the Revelation were recreated literally: by adding eight small onion domes around the central tent, four around the western side church and four elsewhere, the builders indeed created a church with twenty-five "crowns of gold"; this arrangement survived through most of 17th century.[53] Walls of the cathedral mixed bare red brickwork or painted imitation of bricks with white ornaments, in roughly equal proportion.[52] The domes, covered with tin, were uniformly gilded, creating an overall bright but fairly traditional combination of white, red and golden colours.[52] Moderate use of green and blue ceramic inserts provided a touch of rainbow as prescribed by the Bible.[52]

While historians agree on the color of the 16th century domes, their shape is disputed. Boris Eding wrote that they, most likely, were of the same onion shape as present-day domes.[54] However, both Kolomenskoye and Dyakovo churches have flattened hemispherical domes, and the same type could have been used by Barma and Postnik.[55]

Development

1583–1593

The original Trinity Cathedral burnt down in 1583 and was refit by 1593.[35] The tenth sanctuary, dedicated to Basil Fool for Christ (1460s–1552), was added in 1588 next to the north-eastern sanctuary of the Three Patriarchs.[35] Another local fool, Ivan the Blessed, was buried on the church grounds in 1589; a sanctuary in his memory was established in 1672 inside the south-eastern arcade.[4]

The vault of the Saint Basil Sanctuary serves as a reference point in evaluating the quality of Muscovite stonemasonry and engineering. As one of the first vaults of its type, it represents the average of engineering craft that peaked a decade later in the church of Trinity in Khoroshovo (completed 1596).[56] The craft was lost in the Time of Troubles; buildings of the first half of 17th century lack the refinement of the late 16th century, compensating for poor construction skill with thicker walls and heavier vaults.[56]

1680–1683

Murals in the galleries

The second, and most significant, round of refit and expansion took place in 1680–1683.[4] The nine churches themselves retained their appearance, but additions to the ground floor arcade and the first floor platform were so profound that Nikolay Brunov considered the rebuilt cathedral a "new" building and an independent work that incorporated the "old" Trinity Cathedral.[57] What once was a group of nine independent churches on a common platform became a monolithic temple.[58][57]

The formerly opened ground floor arcades were filled with brick walls; the new space housed altars from thirteen former wooden churches erected on the site of Ivan's executions in Red Square.[4] Wooden shelters above the first floor platform and stairs (the cause of frequent fires) were rebuilt in brick, creating the present-day wraparound galleries with tented roofs above the porches and vestibules.[4]

The old detached belfry was demolished; its square basement was reused for a new belltower.[4] The tall single tented roof of this belltower, built in the vernacular style of the reign of Alexis I, significantly changed the appearance of the cathedral, adding a strong asymmetrical counterweight to the cathedral itself.[59] The effect is most pronounced on the southern and eastern facades (as viewed from Zaryadye), although the belltower is large enough to be seen from the west.[59]

The first ornamental murals in the cathedral appeared in the same period, starting with floral ornaments inside the new galleries; the towers retained their original brickwork pattern.[4] Finally, in 1683 the cathedral was adorned with a tiled cornice, in yellow and blue colours, featuring a written history of the cathedral[4] in Old Slavic typeface.

1737–1784

In 1737 the cathedral was damaged by a massive fire and later restored by Ivan Michurin.[60]. The inscriptions made in 1683 were removed during the repairs of 1761–1784. The cathedral received its first figurative murals inside the churches; all exterior and interior walls of the first two floors were covered with floral ornament.[4] The belltower was connected with the cathedral through a ground floor annex;[4] the last remaining open arches of the former ground floor arcade were filled up during the same period,[4] erasing the last hint of what once an open platform carrying the nine churches of Ivan's Jerusalem.

1800–1848

Red Square prior to the great fire of 1812 (Fedor Alekseev, 1802)

Paintings of Red Square by Fedor Alekseev, made in 1800–1802, show that by this time the cathedral was enclosed in an apparently chaotic cluster of commercial buildings; rows of shops "transformed Red Square into an oblong and closed yard."[61] In 1800 the space between the Kremlin wall and the cathedral was still occupied by a moat that predated the cathedral itself.[62] The moat was filled up in preparation for the coronation of Alexander I in 1801.[63]

The French troops that occupied Moscow in 1812 used the cathedral for stables and looted anything worth taking.[64] The cathedral was spared by the Fire of Moscow (1812) that razed Kitai-gorod, and by the troops' failure to blow it up according to Napoleon's order.[64] The interiors were repaired in 1813, and the exterior in 1816. Instead of replacing missing ceramic tiles of the main tent, the Church preferred to simply cover it with a tin roof.[65]

The fate of the immediate environment of the cathedral has been a subject of dispute between city planners since 1813.[66] Scotsman William Hastie proposed clearing the space around all sides of the cathedral and all the way down to the Moskva River:[67] the official commission led by Fyodor Rostopchin and Mikhail Tsitsianov[68] agreed to clear only the space between the cathedral and Lobnoye Mesto.[67] Hastie's plan could have radically transformed the city,[66] but he lost to the opposition whose plans were finally endorsed by Alexander I in December 1817[67] (specific decision on clearing the rubble around the cathedral was issued in 1816).[64]

Nevertheless, actual redevelopment by Joseph Bove resulted in clearing the rubble and creating Vasilyevskaya (St. Basil's) Square between the cathedral and Kremlin wall by shaving off the crest of the Kremlin Hill between the cathedral and the Moskva River.[69] Red Square was opened to the river, "St. Basil thus crowned the decapitated hillock."[69] Bove built the stone terrace wall separating the cathedral from the pavement of Moskvoretskaya Street; the southern side of the terrace was completed in 1834.[4] Minor repairs continued until 1848, when the domes acquired their present-day colours.[35]

1890–1914

Postcard, early 20th century

Preservationist societies monitored the state of the cathedral and called for a proper restoration throughout the 1880s and 1890s,[70][71] but it was regularly delayed for lack of funds. The cathedral did not have a congregation of its own and could only rely on donations raised through public campaigning;[72] national authorities in Saint Petersburg and local in Moscow denied financing from state and municipal budgets.[72] In 1899 Nicholas II reluctantly admitted that this expense was necessary,[73] but again all involved state and municipal offices, including the Holy Synod, denied financing.[73] Restoration, headed by Andrey Pavlinov (died in 1898) and Sergey Solovyov, dragged on from 1896[74] to 1909; in total, preservationists managed to raise around 100,000 roubles.[73]

Restoration began with replacing the roofing of the domes.[71] Solovyov removed tin roofing of the main tent installed in 1810s and found many original tiles missing and others discoloured;[71] after a protracted debate the whole set of tiles on the tented roof was replaced with new ones.[71] Another dubious decision allowed use of standard bricks that were smaller than original 16th century ones.[75] Restorators agreed that the paintwork of the 19th century must be replaced with a "truthful recreation" of historic patterns, but these had to be reconstructed and deduced based on medieval miniatures.[76] In the end Solovyov and his advisers set upon a combination of deep red with deep green that is retained to date.[76]

In 1908 the cathedral received its first warm air heating system, which did not work well due to heat losses in long air ducts, and only heated the eastern and northern sanctuaries.[77] In 1913 it was complemented with a pumped water heating system serving the rest of the cathedral.[77]

1918–1941

Draft of Narkomtiazhprom building on the Red Square, with the cathedral in place (Arkady Mordvinov, 1936)

During World War I the cathedral was headed by protoiereus Ioann Vostorgov, a nationalist preacher and one of the leaders of the Union of the Russian People. Vostorgov was arrested by Bolsheviks in 1918 on a pretext of "embezzling" nationalized church properties, and was executed in 1919. The cathedral briefly enjoyed Vladimir Lenin's "personal interest";[78] in 1923 it became a public museum, and religious services continued until 1929.[9]

Bolshevik planners entertained ideas of demolishing the cathedral after Lenin's funeral (January 1924).[79] In the first half of the 1930's the cathedral became an obstacle for Joseph Stalin's urbanist plans, executed through Moscow party boss Lazar Kaganovich, "the moving spirit behind the reconstruction of the capital".[80] The conflict between preservationists, notably Pyotr Baranovsky, and the administration, continued at least until 1936, and spawned urban legends of the "Lazar, put it back" ilk. Stalin's master planner, architect Vladimir Semyonov, reputedly dared to "grab Stalin's elbow when the leader picked up a model of the cathedral to see how Red Square would look without it" and was replaced by pure functionary Sergey Chernyshov.[81] In the autumn of 1933 the cathedral was struck from the heritage register. Baranovsky was summoned to perform a last-minute survey of the cathedral slated for demolition, and was then arrested for his objections.[82] While he served his term in the Gulag, attitudes changed, and by 1937 even hard-line Bolshevik planners admitted that the cathedral must be spared.[83][84] In the spring of 1939 the cathedral was locked up, probably because demolition was again on the agenda,[85] however the 1941 publication of Dmitry Sukhov's detailed book[86] on the survey of the cathedral in 1939–1940 speaks against this assumption.

1947 to present

In the first years after World War II restorators restored the historical ground floor arcades and pillars that supported the first floor platform, cleared up vaulted and caissoned ceilings in the galleries, and removed "unhistoric" 19th century oil paint murals inside the churches.[4] Another round of repairs, led by Nikolay Sobolev in 1954–1955, restored original paint imitating brickwork, and allowed restorators to actually dig inside old masonry, revealing the wooden frame inside it.[4] In the 1960s, the tin roofing of the domes was replaced with copper.[9]

The last round of renovation was completed in September 2008 with the opening of the restored sanctuary of St. Alexander Svirsky.[87]

Naming

The building, originally known as "Trinity Church",[7] was consecrated on 12 July 1561,[9] and was subsequently elevated to the status of a sobor (similar to Roman Catholic ecclesiastical basilica, but usually translated as "cathedral").[88] "Trinity", according to tradition, refers to the easternmost sanctuary of Holy Trinity, while the central sanctuary of the cathedral is dedicated to Intercession of Mary. Together with the westernmost sanctuary of Entry into Jerusalem, these sanctuaries form the main west-east axis (Christ, Mary, Holy Trinity), while other sanctuaries are dedicated to individual saints.[89]

Sanctuaries of the cathedral
Compass point[90] Type[90] Dedicated to[90] Commemorates
Central core Tented church Intercession of Most Holy Theotokos Beginning of the final assault of Kazan, October 1, 1552
West Column Entry of Christ into Jerusalem Triumph of the Muscovite troops
North-west Groin vault Saint Gregory the Illuminator of Armenia Capture of Ars Tower of Kazan Kremlin, September 30, 1552
North Column Saint Martyrs Cyprian and Justinia (since 1786 Saint Adrian and Natalia of Nicomedia) Complete capture of Kazan Kremlin, October 2, 1552
North-east Groin vault Three Patriarchs of Alexandria (since 1680 Saint John the Merciful) Defeat of Yepancha's cavalry on August 30, 1552
East Column Life-giving Holy Trinity Historical Trinity Church on the same site
South-east Groin vault Saint Alexander Svirsky Defeat of Yepancha's cavalry on August 30, 1552
South Column The icon of Saint Nicholas from the Velikaya River (Nikola Velikoretsky) Miraculous finding of itself
South-west Groin vault Saint Barlaam of Khutyn Undecisive, probably commemorates Vasili III of Russia[91]
North-eastern annex (1588) Groin vault Basil the Blessed Grave of venerated local saint
South-eastern annex (1672) Groin vault Laying the Veil (since 1680: Nativity of Theotokos, since 1916: Saint John the Blessed of Moscow) Grave of venerated local saint

The name "Intercession Cathedral" came in use later,[7] coexisting with Trinity Cathedral. From the end of the 16th century[58] to the end of 17th century the cathedral was also popularly called Jerusalem (noun), in reference to its church of Entry into Jerusalem[4] as well as to its sacral role in religious rituals. Finally, the name of Vasily (Basil) the Blessed, who died during construction and was buried on-site, was attached to the cathedral in the beginning of the 17th century.[7]

Current Russian tradition accepts two coexisting names of the cathedral: the "Cathedral of Intercession on the Moat" (full name: "Cathedral of Intercession of Most Holy Theotokos on the Moat"), which is official,[7] and the "Temple of Basil the Blessed". When these names are listed together, (as in [36][92]), the latter name, being informal, is always mentioned second. The common Western translations "Cathedral of Basil the Blessed" and "Saint Basil's Cathedral" incorrectly bestow the status of cathedral on the church of Basil, but are nevertheless widely used even in academic literature.[7]

Sacral and social role

Trinity Cathedral under construction (Apollinary Vasnetsov, 1902)

Miraculous find

On the day of consecration the cathedral itself became part of Orthodox thaumaturgy. According to the legend, its "missing" ninth church (precisely, sanctuary) was "miraculously found" during a ceremony attended by tsar Ivan, Metropolitan Makarius and divine interference of Saint Nicholas. Piskaryov's Chronist wrote in the second quarter of the 17th century:

“ And the tsar came to dedication of said church with tsaritsa Nastasia and with father Metropolitan Makarius and brought the icon of miraclemaker Nicholas that came from Vyatka. And served a prayer and sanctified water. And the tsar touched the base with his own hands. And the builders saw that another sanctuary appeared, and told the tsar. And the tsar, and metropolitan, and all the clergy were surprised by the finding of another sanctuary. And the tsar ordered to dedicate it to Nicholas... ”

Allegory of Jerusalem

Palm Sunday procession (Dutch print, 17th century)

Construction of wraparound ground floor arcades in 1680s visually united the nine churches of the original cathedral into a single building.[4] Earlier, the clergy and the public perceived it as nine distinct churches on a common base, a generalized allegory of the Orthodox Heavenly City similar to fantastic cities of medieval miniatures.[4][94] At a distance, separate churches towering over their base resembled towers and cathedrals of a distant citadel rising above the defensive wall.[4] The abstract allegory was reinforced by real-life religious rituals where the cathedral played the role of biblical Temple in Jerusalem:

“ The capital city, Moscow, is split into three parts; the first of them, called Kitai-gorod, is encircled with a solid thick wall. It contains an extraordinary beautiful church, all clad in shiny bright gems, called Jerusalem. It is the destination of an annual Palm Sunday walk, when the Grand Prince[95] must lead a donkey carrying the Patriarch, from the Church of Virgin Mary to the church of Jerusalem which stands next to the citadel walls. Here is where the most illustrious princely, noble and merchant families live. Here is, also, the main muscovite marketplace: the trading square is built as a brick rectangle, with twenty lanes on each side where the merchants have their shops and cellars... ”
“ Templum S. Trinitatis, etiam Hierusalem dicitur; ad quo Palmarum fest Patriarcha asino insidens a Caesare introducitur.
Temple of Holy Trinity, also called Jerusalem, to where the tsar leads the Patriarch, sitting on a donkey, on the Palm Holiday.		 ”

The last donkey walk (Russian: хождение на осляти) took place in 1693.[97] Mikhail Kudryavtsev noted that all cross processions of the period began, as described by Petreius, from the Dormition Cathedral, passed through St. Frol's (Saviour's) Gate and ended at Trinity Cathedral.[98] For these processions the Kremlin itself became an open-air temple, properly oriented from its "narthex" (Cathedral Square) in the west, through the "royal doors" (Saviour's Gate), to the "sanctuary" (Trinity Cathedral) in the east.[98]

Urban hub

Intercession Cathedral looms over the streets of Zaryadye (Fedor Alekseev, 1802)

Tradition calls the Kremlin the center of Moscow, but the geometric center of the Garden Ring, first established as the Skorodom defensive wall in the 1590's, lies outside the Kremlin wall, coincident with the cathedral.[2][45] Pyotr Goldenberg (1902–1971), who popularized this notion in 1947, still regarded the Kremlin as the starting seed of Moscow's radial-concentric system,[99] despite Alexander Chayanov's earlier suggestion that the system was not strictly concentric at all.[2]

In the 1960s Gennady Mokeev (born 1932) formulated a different concept of the historical growth of Moscow.[100] According to Mokeev, medieval Moscow, constrained by the natural boundaries of the Moskva and Neglinnaya Rivers, grew primarily in a north-eastern direction into the posad of Kitai-gorod and beyond. The main road connecting the Kremlin to Kitai-gorod passed through St. Frol's (Saviour's) Gate and immediately afterward it fanned out into at least two radial streets (present-day Ilyinka and Varvarka), forming the central market square.[101] In the 14th century the city was largely contained within two balancing halves, Kremlin and Kitai-gorod, separated by a marketplace, but by the end of the century it extended further along the north-eastern axis.[102] Two secondary hubs in the west and south spawned their own street networks, but their development lagged behind until the Time of Troubles.[103]

Tsar Ivan's decision to build the cathedral next to St. Frol's Gate established the dominance of the eastern hub with a major vertical accent,[103] and inserted a pivot point between the nearly equal Kremlin and Kitai-gorod, into the once amorphous marketplace.[104] The cathedral was the main church of the posad, and at the same time it was perceived as a part of Kremlin thrust into posad, a personal messenger of the tsar reaching the masses without mediation by the boyars and clergy.[105] It was complemented by the nearby Lobnoye mesto, a rostrum for the tsar's public announcements first mentioned in chronicles in 1547[58] and rebuilt in stone in 1597–1598.[58] Conrad Bussow, describing the triumph of False Dmitriy I, wrote that on June 3, 1606 "a few thousand men hastily assembled and followed the boyarin with [the impostor's] letter through the whole Moscow to the main church they call Jerusalem that stands right next to Kremlin gates, raised him on Lobnoye Mesto, called out for the muscovites, read the letter and listened to the boyarin's oral explanation."[106]

Notes

  1. ↑ Brunov, p. 27
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 Kudryavtsev, p. 11
  3. ↑ Brunov, p. 39
  4. ↑ 4.00 4.01 4.02 4.03 4.04 4.05 4.06 4.07 4.08 4.09 4.10 4.11 4.12 4.13 4.14 4.15 4.16 4.17 4.18 4.19 4.20 4.21 Komech, Pluzhnikov p. 402
  5. ↑ A concise English history of evolution of the cathedral's names is provided in Shvidkovsky 2007 p. 126
  6. ↑ Brunov, p. 100
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7 Shvidkovsky 2007, p. 126
  8. ↑ Shvidkovsky 2007, p. 140
  9. ↑ 9.0 9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 "Pokrovsky Cathedral (in Russian)" (in Russian). State Historical Museum, official site. http://www.shm.ru/pokrovskiy.html. Retrieved 2009-09-28. 
  10. ↑ "Kremlin and Red Square, Moscow (WHS card)". UNESCO. http://whc.unesco.org/en/list/545. Retrieved 2009-09-26. 
  11. ↑ 11.0 11.1 Kudruavtsev, p. 72
  12. ↑ Brunov, p. 41
  13. ↑ Russian: О Троице на Рву в Москве. Того же году повелением царя и государя и великого князя Ивана зачата делати церковь обетная, еже обещался во взятие Казанскоe: Троицу и Покров и семь приделов, еже именуются на Рву. А мастер был Барма со товарищи. - Full annotated text in "Piskaryov Chronicle, part 3" (in Modern Russian). Full Collection of Russian Chronicles. 1978. http://www.krotov.info/acts/17/azaryin/b61c.htm. , also cited by Kudryavtsev, p. 72.
  14. ↑ 14.0 14.1 14.2 Shvidkovsky 2007, p. 139
  15. ↑ 15.0 15.1 15.2 15.3 Komech, Pluzhnikov p. 399
  16. ↑ "List of federally protected landmarks". Ministry of Culture. 2009, June 1. http://rosohrancult.ru/upload/rosohrancult/rosdocs2009/09_01_2009_1.doc. Retrieved 2009-09-28. 
  17. ↑ Perrier, pp. 96-97
  18. ↑ Watkin, p. 103
  19. ↑ List of federally protected buildings, cited above, names Postnik Yakovlev and Ivan Shiryay the builders of the new Kazan Kremlin, 1555-1568.
  20. ↑ Brumfield, p. 94
  21. ↑ 21.0 21.1 21.2 21.3 Buseva-Davydova, p. 89
  22. ↑ 22.0 22.1 22.2 22.3 22.4 Komech, Pluzhnikov p. 400
  23. ↑ Cracraft, Rowland p. 95
  24. ↑ "Sobor Vasilia Blazhennogo — zaschifrovanny obraz pogibshey mecheti (Собор Василия Блаженного — зашифрованный образ погибшей мечети)" (in Russian). RIA Novosti. 2006, June 29. http://www.rian.ru/society/20060629/50662033.html. Retrieved 2009-09-28. 
  25. ↑ Moffett et al. p. 162
  26. ↑ Watkin, pp. 102-103
  27. ↑ Brunov, pp. 71, 73, 75
  28. ↑ Batalov, p. 16
  29. ↑ Shvidkovsky 2007, p. 7
  30. ↑ 30.0 30.1 Shvidkovsky 2007, p. 6
  31. ↑ Shvidkovsky 2007, pp. 128-129
  32. ↑ Brunov, p. 62
  33. ↑ Brunov, p. 44
  34. ↑ Brunov, p. 125
  35. ↑ 35.0 35.1 35.2 35.3 35.4 35.5 Komech, Pluzhnikov p. 401
  36. ↑ 36.0 36.1 36.2 36.3 Brumfield, p. 95
  37. ↑ Shvidkovsky 2007, p. 128: "regular, not to say "rationalist" plan."
  38. ↑ Brumfield, p. 96
  39. ↑ Brunov, p. 109
  40. ↑ 40.0 40.1 40.2 40.3 40.4 Brumfield, p. 100
  41. ↑ 41.0 41.1 Brunon, pp. 53, 55
  42. ↑ Brunov, p. 114
  43. ↑ Brunov, p. 43
  44. ↑ 44.0 44.1 Komech, Pluzhnikov p. 389
  45. ↑ 45.0 45.1 Kudryavtsev, p. 104
  46. ↑ Komech, Pluzhnikov p. 267
  47. ↑ Brunov, p. 45
  48. ↑ 48.0 48.1 Brunov, p. 47
  49. ↑ 49.0 49.1 Komech, Pluzhnikov p. 49
  50. ↑ 50.0 50.1 Shvidkovsky 2007, p. 129
  51. ↑ Buseva-Davydova, p. 58
  52. ↑ 52.0 52.1 52.2 52.3 Kudryavtsev, p. 74
  53. ↑ Kudryavtsev, pp. 72, 74
  54. ↑ Brunov, pp. 65, 67
  55. ↑ Brunov, p. 67
  56. ↑ 56.0 56.1 Buseva-Davudova, p. 29
  57. ↑ 57.0 57.1 Brunov, supplementary volume, p. 121
  58. ↑ 58.0 58.1 58.2 58.3 Komech, Pluzhnikov p. 403
  59. ↑ 59.0 59.1 Brunov, supplementary volume, p. 123
  60. ↑ Schenkov et al., p. 70
  61. ↑ Schmidt, p. 146
  62. ↑ The moat, fed with waters of the Neglinnaya River, was built in 1508-1516 - Komech, Pluzhnikov p. 268
  63. ↑ Schenkov et al., p. 57
  64. ↑ 64.0 64.1 64.2 Schenkov et al, p. 70
  65. ↑ Schenkov et al., p. 72
  66. ↑ 66.0 66.1 Schmidt, p. 130
  67. ↑ 67.0 67.1 67.2 Schmidt, p. 132
  68. ↑ Schmidt, p. 129
  69. ↑ 69.0 69.1 Schmidt, p. 149
  70. ↑ Schenkov et al., pp. 181-183
  71. ↑ 71.0 71.1 71.2 71.3 Schenkov et al., p. 396
  72. ↑ 72.0 72.1 Schenkov et al., p. 359
  73. ↑ 73.0 73.1 73.2 Schenkov et al., p. 361
  74. ↑ Schenkov et al., p. 318
  75. ↑ Schenkov et al., pp. 396-397
  76. ↑ 76.0 76.1 Schenkov et al., p. 397
  77. ↑ 77.0 77.1 Schenkov et al., p. 473
  78. ↑ Colton, p. 111
  79. ↑ Colton, p. 220
  80. ↑ Akinsha et al., p. 121
  81. ↑ Colton, p. 277
  82. ↑ Colton, p. 269
  83. ↑ "St. Basil's was returned to state list in mid-1930s" - Colton, p. 269
  84. ↑ See, for instance, Arkady Mordvinov's entry for the second phase of Narkomtiazhprom contest (1936), with the cathedral in place.
  85. ↑ Colton, p. 837
  86. ↑ Pokrovsky sobor (Покровский собор). Soviet Academy of Architecture. 1941. 
  87. ↑ "Pridel Hrama Vasilia Blazhennogo otkryvaetsa posle restavratsii (Придел Храма Василия Блаженного открывается после реставрации)" (in Russian). RIA Novosti. 2008, September 2009. http://www.rian.ru/culture/20080925/151581501.html. 
  88. ↑ A "sobor" in Orthodox tradition is any significant church that is prepared to and allowed by the Patriarch to host Divine Liturgy delivered by a bishop or a higher-level cleric. It is not necessarily the seat of a bishop; seat of the bishop, strictly correlating to Catholic cathedral, is "kafedralny sobor".
  89. ↑ Brunov, p. 113
  90. ↑ 90.0 90.1 90.2 Names (patron saints) of the sanctuaries start with the earliest known consecration, as in: Brunov, supplemental tables, pp. 6–10
  91. ↑ Shortly before his death Grand Prince Vasily, father of Ivan, accepted tonsure of a monk under the name of Varlaam. Connection between this event and the Church of St. Varlaam has not been confirmed by hard evidence.
  92. ↑ Komech, Pluzhnikov p. 398
  93. ↑ Russian: И прииде царь на оклад той церкви с царицею Настасиею и с отцем богомольцем Макарием митропалитом. И принесоша образы чюдотворныя многия Николу чюдотворца, кой прииде с Вятки. И стали молебны совершати и воду святити. И первое основание сам царь касается своима руками. И разсмотриша мастеры, что лишней престол обретеся, и сказаша царю. И царь и митропалит, и весь сунклит царьской во удивление прииде о том, что обретеся лишней престол. И поволи царь ту быти престолу Николину... - "Piskaryov Chronicle, part 3" (in Modern Russian). Full Collection of Russian Chronicles. 1978. http://www.krotov.info/acts/17/azaryin/b61c.htm. 
  94. ↑ Shvidkovsky 2007, p. 128, provides a summary of studies of the ideology of the cathedral
  95. ↑ The style of Grand Prince of Moscow, used by Petreius, has been in disuse for nearly seventy years, replaced by the style of Tsar.
  96. ↑ Komech, Pluzhnikov, graphic supplement.
  97. ↑ Bushkovitch, p. 181
  98. ↑ 98.0 98.1 Kudryavtsev, p. 85
  99. ↑ For a graphic introduction of L. M. Tverskoy's concept of concentric Moscow (1950s), see Schmidt, p. 11 and related annotations.
  100. ↑ A popular explanation of Mokeev's theory, in Russian: Mokeev, G. Ya. (September 1969). "Moskva — pamyatnik drevnerusskogo gradostroitelstva (Москва — памятник древнерусского градостроительства)". Nauka i Zhizn. http://rusarch.ru/mokeev2.htm. 
  101. ↑ Kudryavtsev, p. 14
  102. ↑ Brunov, p. 31
  103. ↑ 103.0 103.1 Kudryavtsev, p. 15
  104. ↑ Brunov, p. 37
  105. ↑ Brunov, p. 49
  106. ↑ Russian: ...спешно собралось несколько тысяч человек, проводили боярина с письмом через всю Москву до главной церкви, называемой Иерусалимом, что у самых кремлевских ворот, возвели его там на Лобное место, созвали жителей Москвы, огласили письмо Димитрия и выслушали устное обращение боярина - Conrad Bussow (1961 edition). "Chronicon Moscovitum ab a. 1584 AD ann. 1612" (in Russian). http://www.vostlit.info/Texts/rus13/Bussow/frametext3.htm. 

References

External links

Moscow Kremlin and Red Square
Kremlin Wall
and Towers
Kremlin Wall (Borovitskaya · Vodovzvodnaya · Blagoveshenskaya · Tainitskaya · Pervaya Bezymyannaya · Vtoraya Bezymyannaya · Petrovskaya · Beklemishevskaya · Konstantino-Eleninskaya · Nabatnaya · Tsarskaya · Spasskaya · Senatskaya · Nikolskaya · Uglovaya Arsenalnaya · Srednyaya Arsenalnaya · Troitskaya · Kutafya · Komendantskaya · Oruzheynaya)
 Kremlin birds eye view-1.jpg
Administrative
buildings
The Senate · Building 14 · The Arsenal · Amusement Palace · State Kremlin Palace · Grand Kremlin Palace · Terem Palace · The Armory · Palace of Facets · Tsarina Golden Palace · State Historical Museum
Churches
Cathedral of the Assumption · Cathedral of the Annunciation · Cathedral of the Archangel · Church of Saint Ioann Lestvichnik and Ivan the Great Bell Tower · Church of the Deposition of the Virgin's Robe in Vlachernon · Patriarch's Palace and the Church of the Twelve Apostles · Verkhospassky Cathedral and the Terem Churches · Cathedral of the Intercession (of Saint Basil the Blessed) · Kazan Cathedral
Squares and gardens
Red Square · Ivanovskaya Square · Cathedral Square · Tainitsky Gardens · Grand Kremlin Public Garden · Alexander Garden
Monuments
Kremlin Wall Necropolis · Monument to Minin and Pozharsky · Tomb of the Unknown Soldier · Place of Skulls · Tsar Cannon · Tsar Bell
Former
Ascension Convent · Chudov Monastery · Armorial Gate